Skip to main content

SC-170 · Founder

Building a Music Tech Business Outside the Venture Capital Model

Guest: Sam Reti

Episode notes

What does it take to build a sustainable technology business in an industry that doesn't move quickly?

In this episode of Sound Connections, we're joined by Sam Reti, entrepreneur, musician, and founder of Muzie, a platform helping music teachers deliver high-quality online and hybrid lessons.

Sam shares how Muzie went from a slow launch to serving music teachers around the world, how the business adapted beyond the pandemic, and why building a sustainable company in music education requires a different approach to growth.

We also explore the economics of music education technology, why several venture-backed competitors struggled to survive, and how building proprietary video infrastructure through Hive gives Sam's businesses a competitive advantage.

Subscribe for more conversations on music technology, entrepreneurship, and the business of music.

Produced by Amplitude Ventures AS.

Transcript

Transcribed automatically. Names and terms may be misspelled.

Read the full transcript

Speaker A

Education in music is probably the slowest. And I don't necessarily mean this in a negative way, but it's a very tried and true format. The the amount of people that are interested in having something other than a person teach them is not as much as you'd expect. So the quality of education that you're gonna get from just having a private teacher is so much higher than just using like a learning app or future maybe using an AI model to teach. The the quality, experience, community, and the human feel of the music and all of that still plays a big factor. This podcast is produced by Amplitude Ventures, your partner in early stage startups.

Speaker B

Today on Sound Connections, we're joined by Sam Retti, founder of Muzi, to explore what it takes to build a sustainable music tech business without venture capital. From turning an idea into a global platform to finding a business model that works, we discuss the economics of online music education, the role of AI, and why human connection still matters. Sam, welcome to Time Connections Podcast.

Speaker A

Hey, thank you so much for having me.

Speaker B

So you promised me that we're gonna nerd out today. So I'm looking forward to that.

Speaker A

Absolutely.

Speaker B

Sam, for the people who don't know you, who are you and what do you do?

Speaker A

My name's Sam Reddy. I'm a entrepreneur and musician. I currently run a handful of software companies. I started out as a musician and sort of morphed that into building tech products around music and music education. and now have branched out beyond that field. but that's sort of my main focus. And yeah, you know, I love to build things and create. So

Speaker B

So tr explain a bit more about what your businesses do and and so so we can set the scene for what the conversation is gonna be about today.

Speaker A

Absolutely. So Musy is the our main business. And basically what that does is for lack of a better description, think of it as like Zoom for music teachers. So the biggest issue with online teaching is you can't hear each other when you play your instruments on a typical video call. So Musi solves that problem, but then also expands into more of a virtual classroom to enable high quality online lessons. Now over the years, Musi is about seven years old. So we've had time to develop and build that product. And we've spun off a couple of businesses from Musi as well. some in the music education space, some in more of the video communication space. And so we have a couple of businesses that sort of circle around Musi, but our main focus really is to really empower music teachers. So that they can teach anywhere in the world and the quality and experience is as good as if they're sitting in the same room as the other person.

Speaker B

So let's start with a few hard questions like why does it matter that there's a human teaching you music?

Speaker A

Yeah. music is a slow evolving industry. And that is true for pretty much every aspect of music industry. Education in music is probably the slowest, and I don't necessarily mean this in a negative way, but it's a very tried and true format. The the amount of people that are interested in having something other than a person teach them is not as much as you'd expect. So the quality of education that you're gonna get from just having a private teacher is so much higher than just using like a learning app or future maybe using an AI model to teach. The the quality, experience, community, and the human feel of the music and all of that still plays a big factor. And so you'll see that I mean the stats are all there. There's hundreds of millions of people that take music lessons privately. And so it just it's one of those things that is slow evolving, but it's because it works. So people love that connection still.

Speaker B

So, in most cases w if there's new technology that introduces a new way of doing stuff. Now, for example, let's say AI be more interactive in teaching and then the human teacher. It's only a question of price point. If the difference is way too big, y you will go for the second best. But but that's not my perception of what's happening yet, or yeah.

Speaker A

I I think that's kind of true. Is there's there's two things I think that that fall into that is quality and price point. And for now, as we're speaking today, the quality of like the self-learning apps and the quality of like an AI model teaching you is just not there yet. And the price difference really isn't that significant. I mean, there's a lot of teachers out there where you can get. a weekly lesson for twenty, twenty-five dollars is is within the realm of affordability for a lot of people. Of course, there's people where that doesn't work. And that is when something like an app or something that is significantly cheaper, you know, maybe a ten dollar a month subscription might work. And that's why you do see things like those like piano apps that try to help you learn or like Usition or Flow Keys or Things like that, they have a big market because there are students and people who want to learn and maybe not put much of investment into it. But the market for taking real lessons is still so big that those don't actually pose any real threat to music lessons and often are used by music teachers as supplement for their music lessons. So it kind of works.

Speaker B

So when you describe yourself almost Zoom for music classes of music teachers and their students, I can imagine there's also an opportunity in that disruption for you because teachers need to stay more relevant. Maybe they're not, you know, can't serve their local market the same way they did before. So therefore they need to go digital. So just walk me through the reasoning of your business and how that actually might, you know, ride the wave through that.

Speaker A

Yeah, we our business is really interesting because we got well, I'll unabashedly say very lucky. So we rolled out Musi on January 10th, 2020. And we always joke that the first few weeks nobody signed up. And if there was no COVID, I wonder if Muse would have survived. Because at that time, online lessons were very much an afterthought. They were not A mainstream idea. They were very, very niche. And I'm not sure we could have built an entire company off of that concept. But we rolled out. There's about a month there where we had, a couple people sign up and a couple lessons happening. And we're like, man, we've maybe screwed up pretty bad here. And then the flood dates opened. And it we we always laughed the the week the lockdowns were like officially announced, the first day we had 400 teachers sign up, and we're like, no, how are we gonna how are we gonna handle that? And the timing was just two of us working at the company, and then it just never stopped. we I think got really lucky because of the timing, but also because we thought ahead about something that that made it successful in the long run. So for us, we looked at 2020 and 2021 as Online teaching. You've got to just serve the people that are there that need the help because every studio in the world said the same thing. no, we're going online and I need to somehow keep this thing running. So Musy served that niche and it solved the problem for them. But then about the end of 2021, the question became okay, what does music education look like in the for the next 10 years? And that was a much more interesting conversation because. It really boiled down to a hybrid model. And pretty much what you're talking about is teachers started thinking about, well, where else can I teach? How else can I expand my business? And COVID sort of o unlocked this box for music teachers that most of them had never thought about. Because like I was saying at the beginning, they're very traditionalists. A lot of them just do their half an hour lessons in their house. Student comes in, student goes, and just, you know, work through the day like that. Then all of a sudden you start thinking about hybrid group classes, online lessons, courses, webinars, all of these other things you can start to pack into your business. And so that's what Muse enables in a really simple way is to modernize your studio and grow out of your regional demographic, which I think is the most important thing. So if you're located in a low, lower income area and your lessons might cap out at let's say $30 for 30 minutes. Well, you can now go serve a high income area and you can charge sixty dollars for thirty minutes. or you could have group classes where you charge five times that per session. So the options really start to become quite

Speaker B

Interesting. Hmm. So so let's turn the time it back from before COVID nineteen hit. that, January twenty twenty. what happened before? Like you were a couple of guys had an idea. Like give give the backstory here. Yeah.

Speaker A

Yeah, so music came about in I'd I'd argue it's a unique but also very standard startup way. Is this goes all the way back to 2015? So in 2015, I'm in college at Berkeley School of Music. I'm ready to graduate, but I don't really have anything on my plate. And I'm like, what am I gonna do when I walk out the doors? So luckily I found a class at Berkeley called the Startup Lab, and it was a partnership with MIT. So the cool thing was I got to go into this class and have one MIT teacher and one Berkeley teacher, and they taught real entrepreneurship. Now, to add another layer of lucky, I understand a lot of my life is privilege and luck, so I'm not gonna pretend that I fought my way through things that I didn't. My dad was just about to retire for from his career, which fortunately was in the 80s, my dad was a professional drummer, and in the sort of you know onwards from there he was a software developer. So when I was graduating college, he was about to retire, and I said to him, Hey, I've got to build a product for this startup lab. I have this idea for a little practice app. You wanna work on it with me? And he was like, Yeah, cool. Sounds like fun. Let's build a little prototype. So we go ahead and build this prototype and there's I pitch it in class the next day. And the teachers were like, Whoa, you actually built the whole thing. And So I was like, yeah, I thought that was the assignment. And they were like, we just wanted a mock-up. So for from for very fortunate to have a dad that can can do that, and the knowledge of of music as well. And we actually sold the product back to Berkeley when I graduated as our first client on the platform. So we ran that business for about four years, and that was practice software for college students. So the idea was really high level practice, tracking and monitoring and motivation and Really trying to help college students take their musicianship to the next level. Now we ran that for about four years, but towards the end of the the four years, we started to realize it wasn't scaling, the product had become complicated and clunky, the technology was becoming outdated, and it was really time to sit down and think about what did this all look like in the future. And so we literally sat down one afternoon in my backyard and were like, okay, well, we should probably shut down. This first product. And I've got two ideas for future products. The first was an app kind of like the ones I was describing earlier, where you play and the app gives you feedback. And then you kind of the app basically assesses you and everything like that. at the time, that technology wasn't quite ready. So we did develop it, but we never released it because we just couldn't get the quality to be what it it needed to be. Ironically, now in our current platform, we actually have just one module in our software that is the entire premise of that app just baked into Musy now. So it did come back around eventually. But then we started thinking about Musy and we started thinking about what does it look like for music education going forward. And we both agreed that online was going to happen. And this was in 2018. So this is before lockdowns, before COVID. This is just really thinking about how do we see the future of education. And we'd already seen public schools starting to go online. We had already seen a a whole bunch of other education services going online. And so we were like, well, why isn't music doing this? And so we kind of thought, okay, well, why don't we attack this this first? And so we we did it. And again, it was this sort of funny timing where we built all the technology and we got it all set up and then we launched. And no one showed up and then COVID hits and then boom the thing explodes. And so Muse from that point forward has has never slowed down, even post COVID.

Speaker B

So the business you closed w was that sort of revenue bringing business you could live from it or

Speaker A

Almost, on the cusp, but not really. And that's really that was the ultimate decision on why it needed to go. it it had some pretty good momentum in the early days, and so that's what l allowed us to get the thing off the ground and run it for the for four years. but it just got to the point where it wasn't a scaling, so it was very much a how much work do we really want to do on this for the bare minimum pay that you could possibly. get from from working a startup. Yeah. and and at a certain point like you probably experienced, you just go, all right, we're just this isn't worth it anymore. And it's just not not enough income for the effort.

Speaker B

So so to some degree you you come from a position of not failure, but this this this hasn't gone as well as we hoped. And this is sort of like a an intempt to try to turn that around. Like what was your mentality for 'cause you know, you might, you know, a natural response might have been, let me go get a job. But he said, you know, let me do it again. like why? Why why now?

Speaker A

I there's there's gotta be an addiction because I'm still like that. Even when things are going well. I'm like, what if I tried this other thing? What if I tried that other thing? I think my problem is I have too many ideas and not enough sense to know when to quit. And so it probably the first product probably should have been shut down two years earlier. So I we kind of joke that we beat the dead horse for too many years. And it got to the point where it really was so painfully obvious that if you'd brought anyone from the outside in, they would have been like, dude, this is a complete failure. you need to you need to kill this thing now. And I think for me, that's okay. I don't have that much attachment to the idea or the product. I have more of an attachment to the process of building and sharing and creating. And I think That is a a healthy relationship to have because if something doesn't work, I've had a bunch of failed companies and that's totally fine with me. And it is the typical, that's why I said at the beginning, I have that typical but atypical startup journey, which is I failed a bunch and I learned from every failure. And hopefully I keep failing a little bit, maybe not as much, but keep using that to push things forward. But it's a bit unique because of the the weird way in which things actually fell into, into line to to get me here and to keep going from here. So yeah, I don't know. It's an addiction. I just like building stuff.

Speaker B

Amazing. Okay. that's great. And so let's go back to COVID hits and and you suddenly get four new teachers. for many people, that sounds like a dream scenario, but I can only imagine the stress. because, you know, I can't imagine your servers were ready, like the tech really was that mature that you could, you know, have a false experience. So was that maybe that the joy as some of people would assume when that happened.

Speaker A

A hundred percent. Yeah. Luckily, the so honestly, the tech actually wasn't too much of a problem, mostly because my dad had come from building healthcare infrastructure companies. So he had built the thing to scale pretty massively. Although, yes, there are always hiccups no matter what when it comes to technology. And we were not expecting 400 teachers to show up on the the one afternoon. so there there absolutely were. Technical interruptions, but those weren't the problem, right? Those, luckily for us, because at that point there's just two of us, it was a, hey, here's the bugs, fix them. And he's grinding away all night, fixing every bug that's coming through the door. I think the bigger problem was the pure volume of demos and webinar calls and like help desk tickets and chat support. And it's just me. I mean, the amount of times, if you ask my wife, she'll She'll she'll verify this with a with a bit of frustration. How many times I was up at two, three, four o'clock in the morning on my phone answering support chats for people in, you know, Australia or in India or wherever they were coming from. Because the the the thing is it was a global pandemic. This isn't like we blew up in you know Colorado or something. This was like boom, we have 90 countries using our product and we've gotta now. Make sure all the legal stuff is in place. Make sure all the tax implications are correct. Make sure the amount of other work that you never imagine that you're gonna need to do. And I did not go to business school. So I do not have an entrepreneur degree. I do not have any of this stuff is not taught. This is all learnt on the job, you know? So it was it was chaotic to say the least. But At the same time, it was it was fuel. we were burning on adrenaline at that point. I I vividly remember driving from Colorado to Florida, just a two-day drive. And I was, you know, maybe 20 hours into this drive, and my phone rang and it was like a kind of an emergency tech support. Like we needed to fix it. So I remember pulling over on the side of the road in the middle of nowhere. And whipping out my laptop, tethering it to my phone, and sitting there trying to fix things while we're and then I remember being in a dog park in Georgia, sitting at the park bench, working on my laptop while we're on this little mini road trip. Just because at that time, that is what you had to do to get it to to work. And I I think that type of stuff would actually burn out more people than they would assume. Cause they a lot of people think of it like you're saying of look at the thrill. You must have just seen money flying through the door. It's like, well, no. Actually, at the first week, we weren't even smart enough to charge for the product. So for for a month or two there, no one was even paying us because we hadn't set the set that up correctly because we didn't know anyone was gonna be subscribing. So we yeah, I mean, we were chasing our tails for a long time. It probably wasn't until about September that I feel like we finally felt this like. Okay, we're caught up. We can now handle the flow that's coming in. but that's nine months of running around like a headless chicken.

Speaker B

So, fast forward six years, almost like well, six years, six and a half years. Yeah, you're now running a business. and you know, any company that's on the podcast, you know, I need to understand sort of why one would believe in it. So again, if it's just take it at face value and we say, you know, Zoom for for music teachers, you know, it doesn't sound like, you know, a venture style business. Like it's a isn't it a fairly small niche to serve? Is that a good thing, it's a bad thing, how do you think about it?

Speaker A

Yeah, it's a really, really interesting thing. And it is not a venture style business. And there's a couple of good reasons for that. so the first thing is yes, there's a lot of music teachers. Muse does now serve online and in person lessons, which is part of what we shifted the model to to make sure we didn't get killed at the end of COVID. which is the only reason I think music is succeeding as it is today. But music education is not really a venture-friendly market. We had one, two, three, four, five, five or six competitors but pop up about the same time, right? Kind of riding that first year of COVID. Cause everyone thought, hey, let's jump in on this. All venture backed. Every single one of them is gone. And so There is and there every year or every two years, another one pops up, and then I set my clock for 18 months, and 18 months later, I get an email, and this has happened four times, so I I promise. And the email says, Hey, I know we've been competing in this market for 18 months. Would you be interested in sitting down for a chat? We're looking to offload our business to somebody. And we have been asked to buy so many of our competitors that it kind of becomes a running joke at our company of like when are we gonna get the next email? And it's not because they don't know what they're doing and it's not because they're not good at business or don't have a good product. It's because the market doesn't like venture money. And as I was saying at the beginning, music teachers move slowly. And it's again, it's not an indictment of them as people or the or anything. It's just true. it really is just a fact. If you put I know for a fact that there's a company that put four point five million dollars into ad spend in two years, right? And they ended up with less than a hundred paying customers. So you can do the math on how bad that looks to a to any VC out there. And so that's and that's one of many. There's companies in the market that have had tens of millions of dollars put behind them and have inevitably closed down because the return isn't there. And the return's not there because teachers don't pay huge sums of money for things. They're teachers. They're not making software salary CEO level money. They are making teacher salaries. So you have to understand that. And you have to understand that this is a real long game. The only reason Muse stuck around for as long as it has is because we've refused. To not go away. And we've just outweighed, we've just waited out all of our competition. And inevitably they end up giving us their users as we keep waiting them out. And there's really only two of us that have have stayed in the market for the whole run. and we started just about the same time. And so and that's again, that one's not venture backed. So the two that didn't take the venture money are the only two that are still here today. Now, having said that, I have another company. that is absolutely venture friendly. So that's how we get away with this.

Speaker B

we'll cover that in a second, but I'll try to extend this a bit more. So so how come you you did survive? Try to explain the economics a tiny bit. you charge someone what and how long do they stay and and when you say long term it's because you just need to build up a long tail of like high lifetime value customers to try to break it down close to to how the economics would work then.

Speaker A

Yeah, yeah, you nailed it honestly. It is it's a if you if your listeners are familiar with like sort of software companies, this is a very traditional lifestyle software company where like I was saying it's not a venture-friendly one because we have customers on Musy today that signed up in that first batch of 400 on that first day. And a a large portion of those people are still on the platform today. Our retention rate is crazy high. But the growth rate would scare a VC away because to them they're like the digits are not, there's not enough zeros in the digits for them to feel happy. But over six years there are, So it's that's exactly it, is we built this momentum. So we now do not run ads, haven't run an ad in maybe three years, haven't run we haven't done anything, we don't sponsor stuff. We're actually gonna sponsor a podcast in a few months, but only because it's a friend of ours who's got a cool podcast. so that's really the only thing we've even considered doing in the last three or four years. So Muse is entirely an organic business. So our economics is really straightforward. We charge $12 for the light account, $24 for the pro, and then we have a studio account, which is like an admin can buy us buy seats. for their school, right? And those are 20 bucks per C. So typical is if we're talking just base subscriptions, the light account probably is maybe 40% of our our users. the pro account is probably no, that's probably not true. It's probably 30% light, probably about 50% pro. And then the rest would be our studios. studios are our lowest number but our highest dollar value Because we might have a school with 20 teachers and that's a $400 a month subscription. most of our users are well, we actually it's it's quite interesting, is most of our users have never left. So we have a net positive retention rate in that sense. what's cool about that though is the typical retention from what we can sort of tell is between three and five years. But the problem with that is We're still going, so we don't really know. You know, we don't really know where where that ends. the the and the reason is is because you gotta think about how teaching works. Once these teachers have something that works, and the way Muse works is you onboard all your students, you have all their practice tools there, you have all their files, their lessons, recordings to offload all of that onto something else, the other thing needs to be way better than what we're doing. And we're honestly. We're really good at what we do. We've had a long time to practice. we actually just rolled out a new version of our product about three months ago because we realized, well, the old technology is getting a little out of date. We really need to update for the modern era. And all of our users just moved over. And actually, crazy thing is when we did that, we doubled our paying customer base in two months. So that that sh kind of shows you that for us, we have a reputation in the market where We're known to provide a good service. People like us. Our teachers talk about us. Ironically, our entire sales funnel is Facebook, which is like, if you asked any other business in the world if Facebook has a meaningful contribution, they'd probably tell you no. where LinkedIn, Facebook, LinkedIn, TikTok, Instagram, no use to us. It is Facebook groups. And every day I see posts on there that say something along the lines of, Hey, I use Zoom and I hate it. What do you guys recommend? And I click on the comments and it's Muse, Musey, Musey, and then maybe one or two of our competitors and Musey Muse. And that's okay. They come over, we get them, and we keep going. And so we spend nothing to acquire a acquire a teacher. And so that's the only reason that this works. If we were spending App Movie, it wouldn't work.

Speaker B

It's so interesting. but I I can imagine, I don't know much about video streaming, but I can imagine it's not cheap. Like you you need to have some pretty advanced sort of systems and a lot of redundancy and, you know, a lot of stability in order to make that work. So so how do you sort of balance that as you need to scale with with customers?

Speaker A

Yeah, so we are, to my knowledge, so I can't say for sure, but I'm pretty sure, we're the only platform in the market where we build the video stack ourselves. So this is our other business, which is called Hive. Hive, if you're familiar with Twilio or Agora or Dite or Daily or Live Kit, they are all companies that have developer SDKs. Where companies can take those SDKs and implement video conferencing into their product. Muse is the only platform that I'm aware of in this market where we are that. We are not just a consumer product, but we actually build the entire infrastructure ourselves. So Hive is what we call it, just to separate the brands. and we sell that technology to corporations and other businesses and other providers. And we actually even sell it to our direct competitors. We have we actually have another one coming out in a few weeks, which is a is a direct competitor to Muse and it is running on Musi or Hive. So we cornered this interesting opportunity where we're we because my dad built big infrastructure projects, to him this wasn't that big of a deal. It was all right, I can do that. So he built this whole system and we run off of it ourselves. So the cool thing is our running costs comparative to our competitors is a fraction because we don't pay a vendor. We are the vendor. So we obviously pay servers. We have servers all over the world. Yes, that stuff does get expensive, but it kind of is our business to have the redundancies and to have the infrastructure and have all the back-end technology where This is partly why a lot of our competitors go bust is because I know how much the other SDK providers charge and I know which ones they're using because there's always telltale signs. So a cut a company will come on the market, they'll go get one of the generic SDKs, and then they'll be paying, you know, point zero zero four cents per person per minute and point zero one cents per minute for recordings. And I know I c we Did all the math out because we charge that. So I know exactly how much they're paying at the end of every month for the amount of lessons they're claiming to do. So I can kind of napkin math how long they have left based on whatever round they raised. so we have a really unique insight that our competition just doesn't get. So that's sort of our cheat code to the whole thing.

Speaker B

Hm. So so was it even your dad that sort of just built this whole foundation or did you like have more people come in and take over for him or like what's the situation now?

Speaker A

yeah, it's me and him. It's me and dad just rocking the ship. We've got other well support staff for sales and marketing and stuff, but like when it comes to building, is it's the two of us. We we do everything. So we this is why kind of at the beginning I was saying, I understand how uniquely privileged my situation is. My dad, not to be like, my dad's the best, but my dad is literally one of the he's an original. so he started software development in 1980. So he came up all the way through the trenches. So he can do things that takes a team of 10 people. And the cool thing is now him with a couple of clubs can do things that takes a team of 50 people. So we found that we don't need to scale the d dev side of things nearly as much as we thought we were going to. And so we've been able to scale these businesses. Really lean, really aggressively lean. And that's another reason why these things work. Where I know, in the music space, the first thing that happens is they get around, they hire 15 people, and then they burn through the cash and they're, because they're paying all these crazy salaries that they can't really fund. And so our unique team of really him having the technical understanding, but also the music knowledge, and me having the music and business knowledge that I've gained over over the years, we work really well together in pushing this business forward based on that. Where I think also we've seen a lot of people come in from the outside. So I think there's two things that happen, right? Is a lot of competitors will come in and they have no music knowledge. They're just technology guys. So they're just like, hey, there's a market over there that doesn't seem to have many players. Let's get some VC money, hire a couple of devs and attack this. Problem there is you really need to understand teachers. And if you don't really fundamentally understand the teachers, it's just not gonna work. The other side is it's usually like a teacher who isn't really a software developer, who might be vibe coding something, or maybe as like a friend who can is like a junior level, software engineer who's building something with them. And it's not to I'm not saying they can't do what they do. They can build some pretty cool stuff. But for the scale of what we have, you need a literal industry expert on one end and then just an idiot who can say, you know, point it in the right direction. So so that is our unique factor as a company.

Speaker B

It's so interesting. I can imagine there's also downside to that, right? Because when you're a few people, the responsibility you are also in a few people when things goes wrong. Or, you know, when there's crisis times, you don't have a lot of people to lift. So so how do you handle that sort of mentally? Like as an entrepreneur, that can be tiresome.

Speaker A

A hundred percent. And it r it really can I think people underestimate how close you get to quitting on a daily basis, you know? I think people look from the outside and go, man, you've got like all these businesses and you must be making so much money. And it's like yeah, but no, like it's not it's like the classic grass is greener on the other side. It's like things are going great. I'm happy, I am not complaining, but it is a hell of a lot messier than. People assume it is, and it's a lot crazier over here than people assume it is. So there are definitely times where actually a kind of a funny one, which is so a few months ago we were rolling out the new Musi platform, right? And my dad was in Italy for a vacation, and my wife went in had the baby a month early. So my my sort of chief technical officer is On vacation for two weeks in Italy, and I am completely out of hand because I am AB hospital having a baby. So so the sort of you know, heads of the company are gone, not planned, just we're just not available all of a sudden. And this is in the middle of rolling out the brand new the brand new platform. So we are migrating 30,000 people from one platform to another, and and it's I mean, luckily it went pretty well for for the situation, but I mean. Talk about a headache because I'm like secretly using my phone on the side over here while my wife's not watching. I'm like, no, no, I'm looking at the baby. I promise I'm watching, and it's is I I'm I'm feel like I'm right back to 2020 where I've got every job on my plate all of a sudden. but you just do make it work. And I think over the years we've really learned we've built a business. And an infrastructure that can't just fall apart. It can have problems, but it can't just break entirely. So for us, there's never catastrophic moments. There's definitely overwhelming moments, and there's definitely weeks or months where things do feel like it's all going down the drain. that's tr I think true with every business. But because of the years of work we've put into this, we've we've spent a lot of time consciously thinking about this and saying, hey, should we hire someone to do this or should we build a process and infrastructure internally where we can handle this ourselves? We almost always build and handle ourselves. And I think because we do that, we've gotten quite good at doing that. I'm sure there's a breaking point somewhere, but I don't think we've hit it yet.

Speaker B

So you've been building for seven years. before that you built for four years, so you're eleven years into the journey. what are you building towards?

Speaker A

Hmm. Good question. I I think there's a couple of answers. There's all there's kind of like stock answers I give people for that question. And as true as they are, they're not the whole picture. The the the the answer I always give people, and this is true, is my my first care in the world was music. That's the first passion I ever had. And so there is. What I feel now an obligation to make sure that there's a next generation of musicians. And I think that is still true to what we do. We want to enable teachers to provide education, to make sure that people are still learning music, especially now with AI stuff kind of bubbling over. But having said that, that's not the thing I spend my nights thinking about. I'm more interested in just seeing where it goes. So I think the reason I have so many other businesses is because I do look at the music industry as this sort of sacred place where I I kind of was joking with someone the other day is if there's anybody on the planet right now that has the resources and knowledge to replace all music teachers with an AI, is probably us because we have more recordings of music lessons than probably anybody else, minus YouTube. We have more teachers and students and interactive engagements and data and technical know-how that we could probably build a model that had a face that could see your instrument, that can hear you playing. We have all of that technology in different parts of our product already. And we could probably bring those together to build an AI teacher that would replace music teachers. But we're not gonna do it. And it's not because it's not a cool idea or Not something that would work is because I fundamentally just don't believe in it. And so that is a little bit of a moral, like I'm okay with musy not being the best business ever if there's moral compromises that I don't want to make. And that's a luxury to have. And that's also why I have hive, because I can then go do that stuff elsewhere.

Speaker B

So so tell us a bit about hive, because that's something you build the proprietary tech, the SDK, the videos, and you want to scale this outside you said you sell two corporates and enterprise. what what is your your goal with that then? Is that sort of that full capitalistic commercial pursuit?

Speaker A

Yeah, that one is the I have no qualms with what happens there. I I don't have a stake in the game when it comes to Zoom teams and meet or like the obvious three that people know. Like if we take a chunk out of them or knock them off, okay, cool. That's competit that's capitalism one one. Like that's part of the fun of the game. You know, it's like the David Goliath. Though we have some really interesting ideas for where to take this technology. And we are always sitting around, and this is even since I was a kid. We me and my dad would just sit around and just ponder what would have be the next 50, 100,000 years. And one of the things we've been working on recently, which I'm super excited about, and people I think it's a little early still, because when I explain it to a lot of people, they're not totally sure they get it. But is what we're doing is we are building a we're okay, so the problem we're solving is. I believe in the next 10 years, wearable glasses are going to become the secondary implementation of technology from a phone, right? So everyone's still gonna have their phone, but I think a huge amount of people are gonna have smart glasses. You cannot do a video call on a pair of smart glasses. It doesn't work because there's no camera facing you. So you can't participate in a video call. You can see the video call, but you can't be in it. So, how do you solve that problem? We're working on our avatar project, which we can create completely photorealistic 3D renders of the person who's wearing the glasses. And they can participate in the call by basically puppeting their own avatar. And it uses facial cues and words, the way you speak and head movement and things like that. So to me, when I look at Hive, I'm thinking about The SDK and stuff are great. Those keep the business running. But I'm always thinking, what does it look like in the future to be able to have communication in a new medium? And that so that's really where we're focusing our energy.

Speaker B

Yeah, that's really interesting. It's also something yes, very different. do do you think you're sort of a weird question, but compromising the potential of a conservative b good business by pursuing something that it's sort of trying to knock it out of the ballpark?

Speaker A

I'm sure to a certain degree that that is true. I think with anything, right? You can't give a hundred percent to two things. It's just not possible. So there is always a truth that the more time I spend on these other things is less time I spend working on Musi. It's also true that Musi has a cap. There's a growth limit to that product and platform. And that limit is not high enough for me. And not To say we will can't make millions of dollars and have all these great teachers and help all these people, which is exactly what we do. But to I as I said at the beginning, I'm kind of your straightforward entrepreneur capitalist. Like I my brain sees things with a lot more zeros than than you know, a standard business might. So I I'm always thinking about how do we blow this thing out of the park, partially for a selfish. I want to have that one big unicorn where, who doesn't? But I want that. I want to have the thing that explodes and we sell it and you take your payday and you retire early. That is, always part of the fantasy of of entrepreneurship. In reality, I don't think I could ever retire. I think I'd just go work on something else. But on the flip side, I am genuinely curious about what does the future look like. And if I can have a hand in building or shaping that, I personally think I'd be stupid not to take that opportunity.

Speaker B

So the the the the the beauty about partners is that they might not always agree with things. you just have a a kid eight weeks ago, how well how does your wife think about these sort of grand plans of yours? because you have something you know, I can imagine she's been she's been a witness to your entrepreneurial attorney, right? And it

Speaker A

yeah.

Speaker B

took, you know, four years to get anything off the ground. It probably took a few more years to get something sensible off the ground. And now you're sort of at the place like, we have the opportunity to actually relax if we want. Yeah. but then you take it up another nutch. what what's the reaction there?

Speaker A

Yeah, definitely there's fifty, there's a there's a split reaction. There is a bit of her that is like, please stop. Just please. Cause every day I come to her and I'm like, hey, I have an idea. And you know the first thing is a okay, what's your nother like what's your next great idea? You know, I'm I'm kind of like that annoying like inventor friend who's always inventing something, you know, 90% of it. You're like, this is dumb. Why would anyone want this? so I know she gets a little exasperated with that, but on the flip side, you have your ride and die people. And the way they're ride and die is when we shut down the first company and I had no job and I had no income and she picked up the slack and we were just dating at the time, you know, and it was like and we had just moved into a house. So we had literally just bought a house. We weren't engaged or anything, we did everything backwards. We moved across the country, bought a house, and then I basically lost my job, essentially. And it was a crap, what are we gonna do now? Well, she said, okay, well, I gotta go do something. So she went and got a job and she's done amazingly for herself. She scaled herself. She's now the director of AI at a cybersecurity firm. and her education is that she did two years of college and she was a professional horse trainer. So she's very much entrepreneurial without being my type of entrepreneurial, right? Like she's a go-getter in that way. So I know part of her is a little bit like, please stop. Like let's just enjoy our time. But I think a little bit of her too is like, fuck it, see how far you can take this thing. Like see what you can do with it. Like you know, and then if it doesn't work, there's always backup plans. And I think we're young enough and having enough fun that backup plans don't need to be implemented yet. I l if let's recap this in five years from now or ten years from now, when, you know, the kids are aiming towards school and colleges and we start having those conversations. And if things haven't, you know, scaled exponentially from here to there, then sure we'll probably be having different conversations, maybe selling musy and taking some change, putting that away and making sure things for the next few years are going to be easier. But we're at the point now where I think we're young enough to play a little dangerously. And and I think too for myself, I I I couldn't I couldn't stop now. Is it is like really an addiction to this like just feeling that I have to get these things out of me. And I think being a musician prior, I had the same feeling with music. Like I had this addiction to writing music and getting the songs out of my head. And now I think that's how I feel with ideas and businesses. So as much as she's like, God, not another, like the other day I had her testing, beta testing one of the new Musi apps that's coming out, at the end of the year. So she's she's ride or die. So, you know.

Speaker B

Amazing. Well, it's it's been such a pleasure having you as a guest and dissecting a bit about what you do and and why you do it. but I think it's interesting to hear a tiny bit about your predictions of what will happen with these teachers. So of course you've taken a position of you know, creating the platform for them to enable their business and that, you know, probably will continue for many, many years. but there is also a shift, there is also a shift about maybe humans becoming less and less relevant in that interaction, and technology becoming taking much bigger part. But w what is your prediction ten years from now? How is this gonna look?

Speaker A

There I don't think that it'll have shifted as much as most people suspect. And it's again back to the very first thing I said is the music education industry is the last one to move. It's always the last. We look at public ed, we look at private ed, we look at fitness, is weirdly very parallel to teaching, but always a decade ahead. Fitness apps and coaching platforms were huge. years before any of this stuff touched the music education market. Music education's gonna do the same thing again because I've watched it for the last ten years and it's moved a lot less than you'd expect. If you asked me ten years ago where it would have been now, I would have told you it'd be way different than it is, and it really isn't. So it's not gonna shift as much. Sure there's gonna be more apps, more AI, more vide coded slop probably. But I think realistically, people are still gonna show up to their lessons. They're still gonna wanna play music together. Teachers are still gonna have an impact in that journey. I think you'll see maybe internal shifts, like a lot less of people driving to houses because a lot of teachers do this where they're like, drive to a house, do a lesson, drive to a house, do a lesson. I think that's basically gonna go away. That is getting replaced by online now, anyway. And I I can't see a future where people are driving around to people's houses when you could just do it online. one-on-one lessons are shifting more to group learning now already. So I think you're gonna see that kind of stuff be a lot more popular. And then yes, someone's gonna build the AI music teacher, you know, someone's gonna do it. Whether or not it's the giant industry killer that people might think it is, I just don't think it will be.

Speaker B

So I I just try to remember back to when I was taught music. I I start with music rather late, and that's also why I went into technology music because I didn't have the time to to learn the instrument well enough. and I went to this very weird Russian jazz guitarist and singer that basically did the weirdest like scat singing. and I love working with him, even because his music didn't say me anything and it was just breath work and hippie stuff. But I love because there was so much like physical feedback and recognition from a person and, you know, I might have learned something very little. but for him, like the way he expressed like his satisfaction and joy with me was basically what got me back. and I think no matter how good technology gets, I I seriously doubt you can exchange that. and I think that's also also underbilits your point that the that the motivation for learning needs that human touch because it just takes so long and it's it's so slow to to to be taught that you need that. I think that's a brilliant, you know, answer and it also comes in sort of reflects for me I reflect a bit about the importance of learning music. and I actually had a discussion with with one of the parents of of one of my my my my oldest son's friends and they talked about the importance of culture and music and you know, I come from music so I didn't really completely agree with their reflections, but I started my own thinking like why is learning music important? And maybe you have an answer from me. So why do you think that is important?

Speaker A

I think is important because it teaches so much. one thing I have been thinking about myself a lot recently is I started learning when I was 12. And I remember wanting almost immediately to go to c like music school. Cause I remember thinking like, this is my thing. Like I remember picking up a guitar and being like, yeah, like this is me. And I think by like 13, I was like, all my favorite guitar players had gone to like either were just amazing and had been successful in bands, but a lot of them had gone to Berkeley School of Music or Juilliard or had had these amazing education opportunities. And I remember young thinking, man, I really want to do that. And I actually, when I was 13 years old, I actually picked out the piece of music that I performed at my audition for Berkeley when I was 18. So that's five years. To a 13 year old, five years is like 500 years to, like a like a normal person. So what I think music teaches you is patience and understanding that anything worth doing takes a long time to do. And over the years, I've taken that to a lot of the work I do now, kind of to even reanswer some of the questions you've been asking. Four years to build a business that fails, another year or two to prototype things that all fail. And six more years to build a business that's doing quite well, and then having spin-off businesses here and there. That's 11 years of work. That I think if I didn't have that music education background of spending years working on things, there's no way I could have made it 11 years. And I think that is one of the things that it teaches best. Is obviously if you work in a group, you learn, you know, group skills and communication and give and take and there's a lot of that stuff great for mathematical thinking and creativity and all that science is well backed. But for me, I actually think the biggest thing is that persistence is that if you learn to be persistent and you learn early that there aren't any shortcuts, that there is no magic bullet to getting better at something other than practicing. If you get that ingrained early on, everything becomes easier. And I really believe that that's the most powerful thing that music can teach people.

Speaker B

I think that's a great answer. and that makes a lot of sense. And I think that's also why it's worth preserving.

Speaker A

exactly. Is why I don't want to be the guy that kills the industry. You know, is as much as is I don't want to become the villain of my own story. So I don't want to be the guy that builds the AI model that kills the teaching industry. I I I want to be the guy that walks away going, Hey, look, a million more musicians exist because of the work I did. That at the end of the day is a pretty awesome goal. Whether that's a financially beneficial or positive thing to do. I don't really care, to be completely honest. Again, because I've got other stuff I can go do that can can scratch that itch. So I'm a little selfish and fortunate in that position, but I just that's where I'm at. So it's it's what I want to do.

Speaker B

Sam, it's been a pleasure having you on. thanks so much for sharing your story and and explaining what you do and your business really deeply. I hope it's gonna go well and I hope both for your boring business to grow and for your very exciting venture style businesses to grow. And the future will tell us how that goes. So, Sam, thank you so much for being on.

Speaker A

Thank you so much for having me.

More from Sound Connections

All episodes